The buzz surrounding the new enhanced search engine, Qwiki, sets it up as a game changer. I have even heard it referred to as the possible “Google Killer” by some enthusiasts. Hmmm. It sounds cutting edge and cool, but I wonder if the typical user is really looking for that much of an enhancement to their everyday search queries? What made Google and Yahoo so life-changing was the ability to ask a question and then have the answer delivered quickly and directly. It simplified life in a revolutionary way. The enhancements of real-time search and local search have built upon that concept without creating any delayed gratification. However, I am not so sure that Qwiki will do the same. Its proclaimed bells and whistles seem as though they may be complicating a very functional concept. While it seems like a researcher’s dream, a real encyclopedia on steroids, how many of the millions of searches a day are looking for that much information?
If I am out and about in a particular area of the city and want to know what restaurants are recommended nearby, do I really need a full visual experience at that moment or do I just want “the shortcut answer”? I am hungry and wandering. I want to know where to go quickly to satisfy my appetite, what quality of food I will be getting and how much I can expect to pay for it. This can all be delivered in text form.
While I understand the want and need to bring more enhanced content to the user and I am excited to see the newest, most cutting edge technology; I think that the Qwiki experience may turn out to be “not so Qwiki” after all. There will be times when it will be advantageous and inspiring, but it may not always be needed for a typical search query. Bing, also promoted as a game changer when it launched, struggled on its own and eventually needed to partner with a traditional search engine. This makes perfect sense as Bing is great when there is time to shop, compare and investigate. However, when one is just looking for the short answer, Yahoo or Google do the trick just fine. So, it will be interesting to see where Qwiki lands for the long term in the ever expanding world of search. My guess is that it will be a strong player, but not necessarily ever the new Emperor in town. That said, I look forward to seeing behind the curtain at what Eduardo Saverin and Jawed Karim (no technology startup slouches!) are betting on. There is no arguing with their track records.











